Victorian Southwest Michigan True Crime
Murder and mystery haunt the shadowy corners of the Victorian Era in Southwest Michigan.
Decades after his supposed death in 1846, a litigious bachelor was discovered to have been buried alive. In 1865, a Battle Creek woman, yearning for her lover, used Spiritualism to conceal poisoning her three children. An 1883 unsolved quadruple homicide near Jackson caused two suicides, one attempted suicide and two assassination attempts. In 1891, a ten-year-old girl adopted from the State School in Coldwater one morning was found dead in an icy river two counties away that same afternoon.
Researcher and author Michael Delaware unfurls these and other stories that shocked Michigan and the nation over a century ago.
This book will be released on March 11, 2024. If you order from the author, he will send you a signed copy.
Details
- Pages: 192
- Publisher: Arcadia Publishing
- Imprint: The History Press
- Series: True Crime
- Publication Date: 11th March 2024
- State: Michigan
- ISBN: 9781467156073
- Format: Paperback
- BISACs:
TRUE CRIME / General
HISTORY / United States / 19th Century
HISTORY / United States / State & Local / Midwest (IA, IL, IN, KS, MI, MN, MO, ND, NE, OH, SD, WI)
History Press Author Bio
Michael Delaware is an Arizona native who left home at age eighteen. He lived fifteen years in Georgia, where he worked as a craftsman, artist, salesperson, manager and owner of a stained- and decorative glass door and window business. He moved to Ann Arbor, Michigan, in 1999 and to Battle Creek in 2001. He still lives there today.
In 2022, he launched his podcast, Tales of Southwest Michigan's Past . He is passionate about researching forgotten stories from the Victorian era and is known for his video programs on local cemetery, landmark and biographical history.
Bibliography
- The Tragic Death of Dorrence Williams (1846)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. March 6, 1875.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. October 3, 1887.
1873 Atlas Calhoun County Michigan Battle Creek Township, Section 14. (WillardLibrary.org/local-history)
Gardner, Washington. History of Calhoun County, Michigan: A Narrative Account of Its Historical Progress, Its People, and Its Principle Interests. Chicago: Lewis Publishing, 1913.
Lowe, Berenice Bryant. Tales of Battle Creek. Battle Creek, MI: Albert and Louise B. Miller Foundation, 1976.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Battle Creek, U.S. Census 1840.
Michigan Tribune. August 29, 1846.
History of Calhoun County Philadelphia: L.H. Everts & Co 1877 Page 94 – 95 (University of Michigan Digital Libraries https://quod.lib.umich.edu)
Nelson Township Portage Ohio land records 1832–1837.
Neumeyer, Elizabeth. What’s in a Name? An Anthology of Scene Articles on Local History, 2021. Book printed by Kellogg Community College Print and Document Services. Historical Society of Battle Creek.
Ryan, Daniel J. A History of Ohio with Biographical Sketches of Her Governors and the Ordinance of 1787. Columbus, OH: A.H. Smythe, 1888.
Schoolcraft, Henry Rowe. Narrative Journal of Travels through the Northwestern Regions of the United States: Extending from Detroit through the Great Chain of American Lakes to the Sources of the Mississippi River, Performed as a Member of the Expedition under Governor Cass in the Year 1820. Albany, NYL E.&E. Hosford, 1821.
- The Captain and the Axe Murderer (1848)
Bingham, S.D. Michigan Official Biography. Lansing, MI: Thorp & Godfrey, 1888.
Calhoun County Souvenir 1901. (University of Michigan Digital Libraries https://quod.lib.umich.edu)
Directory of Calhoun County Atlas 3rd Edition 1894.
1858 Atlas of Leroy Township.
Gardner, Washington. History of Calhoun County, Michigan: A Narrative Account of Its Historical Progress, Its People, and Its Principle Interests. Chicago: Lewis Publishing, 1913.
History of Athens pages 209 – 211 (University of Michigan Digital Libraries https://quod.lib.umich.edu)
History of Calhoun County. LH Everts & Co., 1838.
History of Calhoun County. LH Everts & Co., 1869.
History of Calhoun County. LH Everts & Co., 1877.
Lansing State Republican, February 1, 1859.
Marshall Statesman. July 22, 1880.
———. May 16, 1848.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Leroy Township Censuses 1850, 1860 and 1870.
Michigan Marriage Records for Calhoun County, Athens Township, 1846.
- The Murder of John Wiley 1855
Battle Creek Journal. December 14, 1855.
———. February 15, 1856.
———. January 4, 1856.
Democratic Expounder. December 27, 1855.
———. January 10, 1856.
———. November 14, 1855.
———. November 22, 1855.
———. October 25, 1855.
Grand River Times. February 13, 1856.
———. January 9, 1856.
Hillsdale Standard. November 20, 1855.
History of Calhoun County. LH Everts & Co., 1877.
Kalamazoo Daily Telegraph. July 3, 1867.
Marshall Statesman. December 5, 1855.
———. February 6, 1856.
———. January 2 and 30, 1856.
———. November 21, 1855.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Marshall Censuses 1850, 1860 and 1870.
Michigan, Cass County Census 1850
State of Michigan Calhoun County Death Records, 1874.
- Murder on the Plank Road (1855)
Battle Creek Journal. May 9 and 16, 1856.
Democratic Expounder. May 8, 1856.
History of Calhoun County. LH Everts & Co., 1877.
Marshall Statesman. April 23 and 30, 1856.
———. February 6, 1856.
———. June 16, 1875.
———. May 7, 1856.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Bedford Township Censuses 1870 and 1880.
Michigan Calhoun County Death Records 1891
- The Rise and Fall of Old Stark (1857)
Battle Creek Daily Moon. May 4, 1907.
———. October 19, 1907.
Battle Creek Enquirer. March 27, 1910.
Battle Creek Moon Journal. March 26, 1858.
1858 Atlas of Calhoun County.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Battle Creek Censuses 1840 and 1850.
Michigan, Calhoun County Marriage Records 1839.
Marshall Statesman. December 1, 1858.
———. March 17, 1852.
———. March 10, 17 and 24, 1858.
———. March 21, 1860.
———. May 9, 1860.
———. November 3, 1858.
U.S. Michigan State Bureau land records October 1835 and April 1836
War of 1812 Service Records – Leonard Starkweather (National Archives https://archives.gov)
- The Haviland Children Murders 1865
Alexandria Gazette. May 14, 1896.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. December 4, 1891.
Battle Creek Enquirer and News. May 13, 1957.
Calhoun County Atlas 1873.
Chicago Tribune. December 28, 1865.
———. May 26, 1866.
Cincinnati Commercial. December 31, 1865.
City Directory of Battle Creek 1896.
Gladwin County Record. May 29, 1896.
Hillsdale Standard. June 26, 1866.
Jackson Citizen Patriot. April 11 and 12, 2013.
———. February 7, 2005.
———. October 7, 2012
———. “Women in the Big House.” October 1, 2017.
Letter from Louis S. White on Alban Cemetery, September 27, 1931. washtenawgenealogy.org.
Life Behind Bars – the Women of the Detroit House of Corrections. 1875 (University of Michigan Digital Libraries https://quod.lib.umich.edu)
The List 1910 ‘History on Women in Prison’ (University of Michigan Digital Libraries https://quod.lib.umich.edu)
Marshall Democratic Expounder. July 26, 1866.
Marshall Statesman. May 30, 1866.
———. June 6, 1866.
———. November 7, 1866.
Michigan, Washtenaw County Atlas 1856 and 1864 (U.S. National Archives).
Michigan, Washtenaw County, Augusta Township Marriage Records, 1846.
Michigan, Washtenaw County, Augusta Township U.S. Censuses 1850, 1860 and 1870.
Michigan, Washtenaw County Probate Notice on Ira Haviland Estate, 1858.
Milford Times. May 23, 1896.
Phoebe Baker Death Certificate 1910.
Saline Observer. June 15, 1895.
———. May 21, 1896.
San Francisco Call. May 15, 1896.
Sarah Haviland Death Certificate 1906.
Sunday Record [Battle Creek, MI]. December 11, 1898.
True Northerner. May 20, 1896.
Van Buren County Press. June 11, 1866.
Washington (D.C.) Evening Star. June 5, 1866.
William Heaviland (Haviland) Marriage Records 1893 and 1894.
- Dark Secret in a Sandbank (1875)
Atlas of Calhoun County 1873.
Battle Creek Daily Journal. December 2–3 and 13, 1875.
———. March 6 and 7, 1875.
———. October 1, 1875.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. May 30, 1878.
Battle Creek Journal. December 8, 1875.
———. March 22, 1876.
———. September 29, 1875.
Hillsdale Standard. December 14, 1875.
———. March 20, 1877.
———. March 28, 1876.
History of Calhoun County. L.H. Everts & Co., 1877.
Marshall Statesman. March 8 and 15, 1876.
———. June 14, 1876.
Michigan Tribune. May 25, 1878.
Northern Tribune. December 11, 1875.
———. December 25, 1875.
———. February 10, 1877.
———. March 24, 1875.
———. March 24, 1877.
True Northerner. December 17 and 24–25, 1875.
- Death of a Giant: Robert Molyneaux (1875)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. March 10, 1876.
———. May 4, 1891.
———. November 29–30, 1875.
———. October 1–2, 4 and 18, 1875.
Battle Creek Journal. December 1, 1875.
———. February 23, 1876.
———. October 20, 1875.
———. September 29, 1875.
Gardner, Washington. History of Calhoun County, Michigan: A Narrative Account of Its Historical Progress, Its People, and Its Principle Interests. Chicago: Lewis Publishing, 1913.
Hillsdale Standard. March 7, 1876.
History of Calhoun County. L.H. Everts & Co., 1877.
Marshall Expounder. October 26, 1906.
Marshall Statesman. January 12, 1876.
———. November 10, 1875.
———. “The Nye Trial.” December 15, 1875.
———. October 6, 1875.
Michigan, Calhoun County, Battle Creek Township US Census 1870
Morning Enquirer. “Theron Mason Obituary.” November 13, 1903.
Sunday Morning Call. “Robert Ferrell Obituary.” April 26, 1885.
U.S. Census 1880, Washington, D.C.
- The Thomas Lilley Case (1876)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. January 18, 1879.
Belding Banner. September 26, 1907.
Cass County Atlas 1879.
Hillsdale Standard. July 2, 1878.
———. March 20, 1877.
Lake County Star. November 16, 1876.
Michigan, Cass County, La Grange Township, U.S. Census 1870.
Northern Tribune. March 24, 1877.
St. Joseph Herald Press. January 18, 1879.
True Northerner. January 17, 1879.
———. June 28, 1878.
- The Crouch Murders (1883)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. April 8, 1884.
———. February 6, 1884.
———. March 10, 12, 20–22, 1884.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. December 4–6, 10, 12–13 and 31, 1884.
———. November 11, 1884.
DeLand, Charles V, comp. DeLand’s History of Jackson County. 1903.
Detroit Free Press. November 13, 1884.
Hillsdale Standard. March 4, 1884.
Jackson Citizen Patriot. 1884.
Jackson County Atlas 1857.
Jacob Crouch US Land Grant Cert #4722 & 4723, March 16, 1837.
Jacob Crouch US Land Grant Cert #6435, March 20, 1837.
Lake County Star. December 18, 1884.
———. March 27, 1884.
Leelanau Enterprise. November 29, 1883.
Marshall Daily Chronicle. March 5, 1884.
Marshall Statesman. February 8, 1884.
Michigan Death Records, Jackson 1883.
Michigan, Jackson County Marriage Records 1837.
Michigan, Jackson County, Spring Arbor Township, U.S. Census 1840.
Owosso Times. December 7, 1883.
Pinckney Dispatch. January 3, 1884.
———. March 27, 1884.
Pontiac Bill Poster. January 1884
———. November 25, 1883.
South Haven Messenger. February 22, 1884.
———. November 30, 1884.
Summit Township Burial Record of Anne Crouch, December 12, 1859.
Union City Register 1884 (Union City Society for Historic Preservation).
Weekly Expositor. March 27, 1884.
———. November 20, 1884.
- The Lonesome Death of Lizzie Stratton (1884)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. March 21, 1884.
Fort Wayne Daily Gazette. March 25, 1884.
Hillsdale Standard. April 22, 1884.
Kalamazoo Gazette. April 4, 11, 18 and 18, 1884.
———. March 21 and 28, 1884.
Michigan, Kalamazoo County, Alamo Township, U.S. Census 1860.
Nightly Moon. March 25, 1884.
- The Butcher of Dibble Hill (1886)
Battle Creek City Directory, 1880 and 1883.
Battle Creek Daily Journal. August 27, 1872.
———. January 8–12, 1886.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. April 30, 1887.
———. January 8, 11–12 and 14, 1886.
———. October 12, 1885.
Battle Creek Enquirer and News. January 15, 1936.
Battle Creek Sanborn Fire Maps 1887.
Bird’s Eye View Map of Battle Creek, 1880, U.S. National Archives.
Calhoun County Atlas 1873.
Calhoun County, Battle Creek, U.S. Census 1880.
Citizen Battle Creek. April 29, 1882.
———. January 12, 1884.
Marshall Daily Chronicle. January 8–9, 1886.
Marshall Expounder. January 15, 1886.
Marshall Statesman. January 15, 1886.
Martin and Francis White Michigan Marriage Records, 1871.
Michigan, Washtenaw County, Webster Township Map 1856, 1864 and 1896.
Michigan, Washtenaw County, Webster Township, U.S. Census 1850, 1870 and 1880.
Nightly Moon. April 8, 1881.
———. July 15, 1880.
———. May 2, 1884.
Sunday Morning Call. January 10 and 17, 1886.
- The Adoption and Murder of Nellie Griffin (1891)
Atlas of Branch County 1894.
Bay City Times. February 5–6, 12, 21–22 and 27, 1891.
———. March 5, 1891.
Benton Harbor Weekly Palladium. February 6, 1891.
Chatwick’s Plat of Branch County, 1909.
Crawford Avalanche. December 3, 1891.
Detroit News. April 2–4, 14–15 and 29, 1891.
———. February 3, 7, 10–11, 13 and 17–18, 1891.
———. June 12, 1891.
———. March 5, 8 and 12, 1891.
———. May 29, 1891.
———. September 8, 1891.
Gogebic Iron Spirit. February 7, 1891.
———. March 7, 1891.
Grand Rapids Telegram Herald. April 3, 1891.
———. September 21, 1891.
Hillsdale Standard. April 7, 1891.
———. February 10 and 24, 1891.
Jackson Citizen Patriot. February 5 and 12, 1891.
Johnson, Crisfield. A History of Branch County. Philadelphia, Everts & Abbot, 1879.
Michigan, Eaton County U.S. Census, 1880.
Saginaw News. February 4, 7 and 10, 1891.
———. June 13, 1891.
———. March 12, 1891.
South Haven Sentinel. February 7, 1891.
- The Ghost of Farrand’s Bridge (1893)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. August 29, 1896.
———. June 8, 1895.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. January 24, 1895.
Burk, Annis. The Johnson Murder Case. Indianapolis, V.C. Severance [c1895] HathiTrust (https://babel.hathitrust.org) Original copy from University of Michigan.
Hillsdale Standard. July 9, 1894.
———. June 18, 1894.
———. September 8, 1896.
Marshall Expounder. March 7, 1902.
Marshall Statesman. July 5, 1895.
Owosso Times. June 12, 1896.
Saline Observer. September 10, 1896.
St. Joseph County Atlas, 1897.
Yale Expositor. September 4, 1896.
- Coins for a Horse: The Murder of Leroy Rogers (1894)
Battle Creek Daily Journal. April 4 and 27, 1895.
———. December 13–14, 18, 20 and 23, 1895.
———. February 7, 13–14, 16, 18, 20–21 and 26, 1895.
———. January 26, 1894.
———. March 23–25 and 29, 1894.
———. May 31, 1894.
Battle Creek Moon. April 2, 9, 15–16, 25, 27 and 29, 1895.
———. April 22, 1897.
———. February 5, 7–14, 16, 18–21 and 25, 1895.
———. January 4, 1895.
———. January 26, 1897.
———. March 4 anf 6, 1897.
———. May 6 and 14, 1895.
Democratic Expounder. May 26, 1894.
———. June 1, 1894.
Hillsdale Standard. May 29, 1894.
———. June 5, 1894.
Kalamazoo County, U.S. Census, 1910.
Marshall Daily Chronicle. May 23–24, 26 and 31, 1894.
Michigan, Allegan County, U.S. Census 1880.
Michigan, Barry County, Rutledge Township Atlas 1860.
Nightly Moon. April 9 and 14, 1881.
———. July 2, 1884.
———. March 29, 1881.
———. November 5, 1883.
Owosso Times. May 25, 1894.
Saline Observer. 1897.
South Haven Sentinel. June 2, 9 and 16, 1894.
Sunday Morning Call. August 31, 1884.
- In Cold Blood: The Murder of James Robinson (1894)
Alma Record. December 6, 1895.
———. March 8, 1895.
Battle Creek Daily Moon. February 27, 1895.
Detroit Detroiter Absend-Post. December 30, 1918.
Escanaba Daily Press. December 23, 1911.
Michigan, Branch County, Coldwater Township Atlas 1894.
Michigan, Branch County Marriage Records 1894.
Hillsdale Standard. February 12, 1894.
———. July 13 and 17, 1894.
———. March 5, 1894.
South Haven Sentinel. February 9, 1895
———. July 28, 1894.
Weekly Expositor. July 20, 1894.
- The Deadly Porridge of Mary Sanderson (1898)
Alpena Evening News. December 26, 1898.
American Biographical History of Eminent and Self-Made Men, Michigan Volume. Cincinnati, OH: Western Biographical Publishing, 1878.
Battle Creek Daily Journal. December 11, 14–16, 18, 20–21 and 23, 1899.
———. March 6, 1899.
Battle Creek Moon. April 5, 1900.
———. April 10, 1897.
———. February 28, 1902.
———. March 5–6 and 11–12, 1902.
———. November 29, 1898.
———. November 26, 1898.
———. October 24, 1898.
———. October 24, 1901.
Marshall Daily News. December 14 and 27, 1899.
Marshall Statesman. December 29, 1899.
Rudolphus Sanderson Death Certificate, September 6, 1898.
Saline Observer. December 15, 1898.
———. November 3, 1898.
Sunday Record. January 8, 1899.
True Northerner. December 27, 1899.
Wisconsin, Sauk County, Fairfield Township, U.S. Census 1880.
For More Information
For researchers in search of more details on the information provided in this bibliography, they can contact the author directly with their inquiries.
